Critics claim fading stars unlikely to shine on in India

Pires became the latest big overseas name to sign up for the tournament on Monday when the former France international joined ex-Arsenal team mate Freddie Ljungberg in the eight-team Indian Super League (ISL) scheduled from Oct.


12 to Dec. 20.

While the 40-year-old Pires has yet to be confirmed on the roster of a specific team, Spanish World Cup-winner Capdevila agreed to join North East United on July 16.

Capdevila’s compatriot Luis Garcia will represent the Kolkata franchise, co-owned by Atletico Madrid, while the former Liverpool and England goalkeeper David James has also committed to playing in the league.

“I am very happy to be part of the new league when passion for football in India is on the rise,” ISL’s official Tweeter feed (@IndSuperLeague) quoted Pires as saying.

“It will be great to play in front of enthusiastic Indian fans as well as share my knowledge with my team mates,” the former Arsenal midfielder added.

However, not everyone is convinced that the marquee players, all well past their prime, can impress upon either the fans or local players.

“It’s a good marketing strategy but in the end, it all boils down to the standard of football,” former India player Satyajit Chatterjee told Reuters.

“Young fans want good football and they’ve grown up watching the English Premier League, La Liga and the Bundesliga. They won’t settle for anything less.

“I don’t think over-the-hill players can dish out that kind of football,” said Chatterjee, considered one of India’s best attacking midfielders.


“The first season will have a novelty factor but how do you sustain the interests of fans who have sampled top class soccer? They are likely to feel disappointed.

“I still believe the organisers should have roped in current players from Europe or Latin America, even if it’s not a (Lionel) Messi.

“It’s a new effort and I welcome it. But I’m not sure having retired footballers as your marquee player is a great idea,” said Chatterjee, who played 15 consecutive years at Mohun Bagan until 2000 and briefly coached the club as well.

Soccer writer Jaydeep Basu felt ISL, modelled on the Indian Premier League Twenty20 tournament, was a natural destination for the ageing players.

“They are done with top class soccer and the space is shrinking for them. Good money and the comparatively brief duration of the tournament make ISL a natural choice for them,” Basu said.

“We should have reasonable expectations from them. Football is not a place for a one-man revolution. They can’t lift the standard of the game here, which depends on so many other factors.”

Cricket is firmly established as India’s number one sport while the country of 1.2 billion languishes 151st in the latest FIFA world rankings.

“Even the ISL seems beset with teething problems. They already have had three postponements and beyond their marketing drive, they are yet to establish a concrete structure with technical personnel,” Basu lamented.

(Editing by John O’Brien)